How I Fill In My Eye Brows + Best Brow Products for Strawberry Blondes

by Molly Gardner
best eye brow brows for strawberry blonde redheads hair products tutorial

My eye brow routine and favorite products for strawberry blondes has probably been one of my most requested videos and posts this year!  It took me so long to put this together because I felt like I hadn’t found that perfect combination of shades yet to match my darker brown brows to my colored light red hair.

I have tried at least 50 different brow products and countless combinations of them.  Every brow look was coming out either too red and fake looking, super muddy, or really dark.  I just never felt like I had the right combination to share until this now.

This tutorial is best for people who color their hair, like me, and are trying to match their natural brows to their new hair color.  If you are a natural redhead, you can skip using the darker color and begin step 1 with the caramel shades.

My Go-To Brow Routine for Strawberry Blonde Hair

1 | Shape

This step is so important!  This is where I went wrong for so long by trying to use Taupe or Blonde shades as my outline shade.  Once I found the pencil shade that matches my natural dark brown brow hair exactly, it’s been smooth sailing.  Getting a perfect match makes all the difference.

Creating the outline and shape of your brows allows you to make them even and fill in bald patches.  I over tweezed and had those super thin 90’s brows that were really popular.  My bald patches are finally growing back thanks to serums, but I definitely still have some sparse areas.

My brows are completely different shapes and sizes, so creating an outline helps even them out and give a nice sense of proportion to my face.

Important Details |

  • Pressure is really important with this darker shade.  I am barely touching my skin.  If you press too hard, the color will come out way too dark and unnatural looking.
  • It’s also important to only draw little lines that look like brows, instead of one continuous line.  Just think of drawing one brow hair, then pick up your pencil and draw another.  Practice on your hand first if you need to.
  • Start at the arch and fill in that area first.  You’ll be surprised how much creating the tail of the brow first changes the look of your face.  Most people barely need any product at the beginning of the brow.  Filling in the arch and tail of brows first will help you get a much more natural look.
  • From the arch to the tail and the area right before the arch, I use horizontal strokes.  At the beginning of the brow, as you’ll see in the video, I switch to vertical strokes to mimic the way my brows naturally grow in.

2 | Red Tones

Now that my brows have structure, I start to add in the reddish tones.  I like the Anastasia Beverly Hills products because they have the most real-looking red shades.  Nothing is too warm or overly red.  I will take either the brow wiz, pencil, or occasionally dip brow (but it’s easy to go overboard with dip brow!) and start to add some brow-like strokes at the arch and then beginning of my brows.

I still keep the pressure light with the Caramel shades, to keep the overall effect soft vs bold.  Side note, using this soft pressure also means you use less product, so your brow wiz’s will last longer!

3 | Set

Brow gel helps keep the brows in place and makes the pencil products last longer.

Again, I like Anastasia’s tones the most for brow gel, as the caramel shade is a perfect balance of reds and browns.  Also, the formula has a satin finish, which is important, as the satin mimics the look of a natural glossy brow hair.  You don’t want to get a formula that is too glass-like, glittery, or matte.

Anastasia Beverly Hills really nails the shades and product finish, which is why I end up using so many of her products.  Btw, this post isn’t sponsored (I wish it was!), I just truly think ABH has the most natural looking brow shades and textures.

4 | Create Hair

I like to create a few vertical hairs at the beginning of my brows.  I’ve found that this gives them a softer and lighter look.  It also helps even them out and make them look more similar.

I use the tiniest amount of dip brow to make these “hairs.”  I scoop a small bit onto the lid of the brow container. The amount is important to keep the brow stroke looking natural.

From there, I get enough to make a thin line and test it on the lid to make sure I don’t have too much product on the brush.  It’s important to use a brow brush that is super thin, but still has a nice amount of pressure.  The thin tip is important so that you can create a brush stroke that looks like real hair.

Starting at the base of the front of each brow, I draw a thin line from bottom to top.  I create anywhere from 2-4 brow hairs on each side.

I do the dip brow after the gel, because I found that any blending (from the gel brush) made the dip brow look muddy and I prefer the lines to stay crisp.

5 | Clean Up

This step is really important.  Clean up the edge of your brows with either an eyeshadow or concealer one shade lighter than your skin.  This makes your brows look really polished and helps keep the brow products in place all day.

Take either a bit of powder shadow or a concealer that sets to dry finish on a concealer brush.  Make sure you have only a tiny amount of product on the brush.  Using the thin side of the brush, draw a line directly below and then above the arch of your brow and then blend away from the brow.

________

And … that is my whole brow routine.  I know it’s a ton of products, but because I only use a little of each, they last me forever.

In the video it takes me a bit longer, as I’m talking through each step.  In day-to-day, this brow routine takes me five to six minutes total. I’ve done it in one to two minutes in a complete rush.

Even if I’m only wearing a little foundation, concealer and bronzer that day, I always make sure to have my brows done, as it makes such a huge difference in pulling my look together.

________

Shop The Post 

lashes | “Double Tapped” from www.girlgetglamorousHAIR.com

Thin Brow BrushesDose of Colors (goes in and out of stock) | It Cosmetics | abh brow brush #14 |

amazon . ulta . sephora . cult beauty (worldwide shipping)

Brow Wiz | shades used: ebony + caramel

ulta . sephora . nordstrom . dilliard’s . beauty bay (worldwide shipping)

Brow Gel | shade used: caramel

ulta . sephora . nordstrom . dilliard’s . beauty bay (worldwide shipping)

Dip Brow | shade used: ash brown

ulta . sephora . nordstrom . dilliard’s . beauty bay (worldwide shipping)

skin tone eye shadow | mac blanc type is a good pick for fair skin

concealer brush

________

blank

________

Similar Posts |

________

Social Links: Facebook (I use this a lot for flash sale links) | Instagram @girlgetglamorous | Instagram hair extensions@girlgetglamorousHAIR | Pinterest (join over 1.3 million other monthly viewers) | Subscribe (free!) for the latest posts straight to your inbox

Thank you for reading and being a part of the blog!

beauty blog blogger los angeles best of reviews tutorials hair makeup

You may also like

Leave a comment below...

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.