You might also like
Makeup
Makeup 
FOLLOW ALONG HERE
GLAMOUR, delivered
Welcome to the GirlGetGlamorous blog!
Subscribe for monthly emails of the latest
blog posts and videos, sent right to your inbox.
X
Is Beauty Pie Worth It? Reviews of Every Product I’ve Tried from this Affordable Luxury Beauty Brand
In this post, I am reviewing every single product I have tried from Beauty Pie. I’m really excited to do this review, because a few of the Beauty Pie products have become staples for me and are absolutely worth the purchase price!
If you are unfamiliar with Beauty Pie, they offer high quality beauty products, priced affordably. They do this by offering an annual subscription service and selling direct-to-consumer. Think of it as Costco, but exclusively for beauty and online only.
You can order from Beautypie with a membership to get the discounted prices or without a membership and pay a higher price. Their current membership options are: a 2 week free trial, a $29 annual option that lets you order 4 times a year ($7.50 per order), and a $59 unlimited option ($5 per month) that allows you unlimited orders at the discounted rates.
Personally, I don’t love subscription based business models, (don’t get me started on my apple+ charges!) but I do understand that in this case, their business model allows the company to plan for how much of each product to order. Also, the products I do love from Beauty Pie are so good that I don’t mind dealing with the membership.
Let’s get into the reviews. Since 2021, I have placed 20 orders with Beauty Pie and received 3 PR packages, so we have 40 products to talk about!
To keep this streamlined, I started with my top 10 BeautyPie products and then have mini reviews for each other other products I have tried.
My BeautyPie Must Have Products
1 | Perfumes – Out of all the perfumes I’ve been lucky enough to try, one of my all-time favorite scents is Figuier de Dalmatie. This was a limited edition perfume that quickly became my signature scent. I had to buy another bottle off a resale website.
It’s finally been brought back and I immediately purchased two bottles to have back stock in case it gets discontinued again.
BeautyPie perfumes have a very luxe finish on the skin, they smell rich and high-end.
Figuier de Dalmatie is my personal favorite because it has notes of fig, without being sweet. I get compliments on this perfume every time I wear it.
This perfume is my #1 pick from BeautyPie!
2 | Candles – BeautyPie candles are another product they do exceptionally well. Both their perfumes and their candles are developed in Grasse, France, where the world’s finest fragrances are made. Side note, I would love to do a trip here and tour the perfumeries!
These candles smell expensive. They are absolutely comparable to my luxury candles that are 3-4 times the cost of the BeautyPie.
My personal favorite scents are Clean House, Bahia de Miel, and a leather and tobacco leaf scent (trust me on this one!) that I hope is brought back soon.
I do like to try all their limited edition releases as well. These candles are my most repurchased product from BeautyPie.
MAKEUP
3 | Ultra Colour Pro Gel Eyeliner – I usually prefer a traditional pencil liner to a gel formula, but these gels liners are SO richly pigmented and smooth that I have now used several of these liners down to the stub.
The creaminess of the formula makes it easy to get color right to the base of my lashes. Both of their liner formula are comfortable for my sensitive skin and eyes.
My favorite liner shade is Molten Bronze, but I also love the Copperhazy and Glamoflage shades.
4 | Supercolour Kohl Eyeliner – This $10 pencil eyeliner quickly became a “must repurchase” in my kit. It sharpens beautifully to a crisp point and glides smoothly at my lash line.
The opposite side has a foam smudger to blend out or clean up liner as needed.
It’s a perfect product. 10/10, no notes. I buy the Brown Beauty shade, a rich matte brown.
5 | Wonderfilter Brightening Primer
My favorite primer! This is super lightweight and makes my skin look fresh and dewy, but never sweaty. It’s my secret to glowing makeup.
This formula was developed in South Korea, where some of the world’s most innovative beauty labs are found.
This primer is very gentle on my sensitive skin and has worked with all of my foundations. I love it!
6 | Triple Beauty Luminizing Wand Highlighter
This is a super shiny, gorgeous highlighter! It’s liquid, so it ends up still looking natural.
I usually apply it first, then foundation, and it creates a lit-from-within glow. Sometimes for extra highlight, I’ll add another tap on top of my foundation.
I am on my third tube of this highlighter! It’s a must-have product for me and an incredible price for this quality level.
I use shade “Wonderwhirl” which is a lovely champagne shade that works on my fair skin.
7 | SuperLuminious Under Eye Color Corrector
When Becca Beauty closed, I went on the hunt for a replacement for their famous under eye color corrector.
Out of all the correctors I tried, the BeautyPie stood out as one of my favorites. I actually preferred it to the Becca formula!
It’s a bit lighter in texture vs the Becca, but still has the gorgeous reflect that instantly brightens and corrects my darker circles before concealer. And yet again with Beautypie, the price can not be beat.
I am on my second pot of this product.
8 | Wondercolour Longwear Eyeshadow Stick
I have tried just about every brand of shadow stick available and the BeautyPie sticks really stand out as one of the top formulas! The colors, especially of the shimmers and metallics, have very high end finish.
The Wondercolour eyshadows have great longevity and give me a decent amount of time to blend before they set.
My favorite shades are Little Star (inner corner highlight) and Huntress (lower lash line and upper lid all over.) I just ordered the shade Tea Rose as well as their limited edition holiday set (3 sticks for $23) and will update on those shades when I get them!
Skincare
9 | Traceless UVA/UVB SPF 30 Mineral Sunscreen + Primer
Having very sensitive skin, I typically shy away from mineral sunscreens. I received this sunscreen in one of the PR shipments and was hesitant, but curious to try this.
From the first application, it absolutely wowed me. The texture feels light. It sinks in wonderfully. And this sunscreen does not even give the sun a chance!
We are talking no burns, no Melasma brown spots popping up, nadda. This sunscreen really works and is comfortable to wear. It’s become my husband’s favorite face and neck sunscreen to wear as well.
On our second bottle currently and will repurchase!
10 | Youthbomb 360 Radiance Concentrate Serum
The Youthbomb serum was another product that came to me via PR. I am so grateful for that, because I do tend to spend more on makeup to test, rather than skincare.
This serum lives up to both it’s name and the hype. It retails for $49 for 1.69 oz at member pricing and performs like a serum 2-4x that cost.
It’s gentle on my sensitive skin, but does help my skin get a nice glow with regular use. It’s lightweight and settles nicely into my skin and under all my face creams and oils.
Everything Else I’ve Tried
11 | Brow Pencil – The medium brown came out too dark on me and the blonde too light. The formulas on both the skinny and the triangle are ok, but didn’t stand out to me. I think there are better K-beauty brow options at this price point.
12 | Quick Color Contour Supergel – I’ve just started using this liquid bronzer and already love it. It has a very natural finish. I’m feeling like this might become a staple for me. It also comes in three shades: light, medium, and deep.
13 | Awesome Bronze Cream Bronzer – I liked the pot formula and texture, but the color was too warm and orange for me.
14 | Elastic Repair Treatment for Damaged Hair – ok, I think meant to be a protein or bond-builder dupe, but wouldn’t repurchase. I think they discontinued this product.
15 | Supercheek Cream Blush Pot – I liked the pot formula, just none of colors I tried suited me.
16 | Mascara – The tubing formula looked really nice on, but did irritate my sensitive eyes. The waterproof version was great for length and volume and did not budge, but I couldn’t remove it even with my DHC oil, so if you try this, get the kit with the bi-phase remover.
17 | Everyday Great Skin Concealer – had high hopes, was formula was average in my opinion. I also wish they would do sample cards for all their complexion products to be able to shade match more easily, as you can’t exchange or return BP cosmetics after opening them.
18 | Everyday Great Skin Foundation – same as concealer, didn’t wow me. Hard to color match and can’t be returned after swatching.
19 | Super Luminous Skin Tint – meh, will use up on my neck and chest. I would try the reformulated version, which is supposed to have more coverage. This version was too sheer. I prefer the Wonderfilter primer to this tint for a skin glow, but will update if I try the reformulated one.
20 | Futurelipstick Luxe Shine lipstick – nice sheer texture. Shades I tried were a “miss” for me, all too cool.
21 | Keep This Eye Shadow Quads – I wanted to love these eyeshadows, but the shades were only “ok” on me. Formula was decent, just not my personal favorite as it was more heavily pigmented than I prefer.
22 | Superluminous Redness Corrector – This was a bit too thick for me. The texture is the same as the under eye corrector, which is perfect on the thinner skin under my eyes, but the green corrector felt too thick when applied around my nose and chin. Also, it didn’t sit well under my foundation.
23 | Wondergloss Collagen Lip Oil – A very nice formula! I typically reach for traditional lipsticks, but this is the best lip oil formula I have tried. Very hydrating and the colors are gorgeous. If you love lip oils, this is a fabulous formula. My favorite shade is Spicy Pink.
24 | Futurelipstick Refillable lipstick – Nice formula, I just bought the wrong shade, so didn’t get to wear it much. I’l purchase again eventually to test a new shade (maybe Takeover or Bare Pink).
25 | Micro-Caviar Overnight Moisture Mask Face Cream – interesting texture. Have only tried a few times but will continue to use.
26 | Luxe Shine Cream Blush Stick – beautiful colors, but 1: I prefer a cream blush in a pan so I can pick up on a brush to apply (easier to control the application) and 2: this cream formula didn’t dry down on me, it stayed creamy. I prefer a formula that is eventually dry to the touch on my skin, but this is just a personal preference.
27 | Awesome Bronze Powder Bronzer – I liked this formula a lot! I especially like that you can purchase just refill pans, great to be eco-friendly or for someone like me who wants to pop it into a magnetic palette.
28 | Superdose Vitamin C Skin Lotion – I didn’t love the texture/dry down. Gifted to a friend for her to try.
29 | Japanfusion Genius Lift Serum – felt nice, but haven’t noticed any major results. Might give to a friend to try.
30 | Super Healthy Skin Uber Youth Eye Cream – nice thick texture and hydrating, but didn’t notice huge results. I’ll use it up, but not sure on repurchasing at the moment.
31 | Lash Fuel Peptide Growth Serum – was definitely more gentle on my eyes vs serums that do contain prostaglandins, but still irritated my sensitive eyes eventually.
32 | Dr Glycolic Soft Foot Peel – fine but not memorable and not as effective as the original baby foot. I forgot that I had tried this until I went through my order history.
33 | Triple Hyaluronic Acid Moisturizer – nice product! Not a noticeable difference compared to my current routine, but I liked it and will keep using.
34 | Super Healthy Cream – nice, thick texture. A great cold weather night time moisturizer.
35 | Makeup Brushes – better than anticipated, but none that took over in my makeup routine vs my other brushes I already owned. Their best brush in my opinion is their concealer brush, which is nice for buffing out any concealer lines.
36 | Makeup bags – decent quality, good zippers. Would repurchase, but found a travel toiletry bag I prefer with a handle.
37 | Silk Hair Scrunchies – nice quality silk, but the interior hair band broke pretty quickly, so they had to be thrown out. Would not repurchase.
38 | Renewed Density Hair Growth Serum – didn’t irritate my scalp, but also didn’t notice major results.
39 | Seven Oil Hair Elixir – meh, a bit too thick for me personal preference. Didn’t notice major hair healing.
40 | Super Healthy Hair Mask – an okay hair mask, but there are better k-beauty finds for around the same price point.
LEAVE A COMMENT